<link href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Inter:ital,opsz,wght@0,14..32,100..900;1,14..32,100..900&family=Nunito:ital,wght@0,200..1000;1,200..1000&family=Caveat&display=swap" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" />

The Zodiac Signs That Just Can't Keep a Secret 🤫

Who spills the gift before Christmas, and who takes your secrets to the grave? From Gemini to Scorpio, here's how all 12 signs rank when it comes to a secret.

Last updated by Susan Taylor

The Zodiac Signs That Just Can't Keep a Secret 🤫

Can You Keep a Secret? Here's Where Your Sign Stands 🤫

There's the friend who's known since October what you're getting your sister and holds out until Christmas morning, and the one who blurts out “you're going to love the sweater” on December 2nd. I'll be honest with you: keeping a secret doesn't come easy to everyone, and your sign has a lot to do with it. Just to be clear, a sign that can't keep a secret isn't one of the biggest liars. Quite the opposite: it's usually too much spontaneity, a need to share, a tongue that runs faster than caution.

Air sign or Water sign, mutable or fixed, ruled by Mercury or by Pluto: traditional astrology knows exactly who passes secrets around and who keeps them under lock and key. Here are all 12 signs, from biggest blabbermouth to total vault, followed by the full ranking. Ruined the surprise last year? My lips are sealed (promise).

✦

From Blabbermouth to Vault: How the 12 Signs Handle a Secret 🗝️

♊ Gemini

Planet: Mercury — Element: Air
🥇
May 21 – June 20
Gemini — can't keep a secret

“I won't tell a soul… except Jessica”

An Air sign, mutable and ruled by Mercury, the planet of words and messages: traditional astrology couldn't have made you any chattier. To you, a secret is information, and information is meant to travel. You're not betraying anyone, you're just “keeping people in the loop.”

The worst part? You don't even notice: the secret slips out between two stories, in the middle of a four-minute voice note. Before you share, ask yourself: is this mine to tell? Luckily, your wit makes you the best storyteller at the holiday table (just pick a different story).

blabbermouth meter 92%

Vault Blabbermouth

♐ Sagittarius

Planet: Jupiter — Element: Fire
🥈
November 22 – December 21
Sagittarius — can't keep a secret

“Oops, did I say that out loud?”

A Fire sign, mutable and ruled by Jupiter, the planet of big, bold enthusiasm: for you, honesty is a religion and a filter is an optional feature you rarely install. You don't mean to reveal anything, you're just too excited to stay quiet.

The surprise party? You announced it with a laugh (“Act surprised, okay?”). When someone tells you a secret, repeat “I heard nothing” three times. Luckily, your honesty is disarming: people always forgive you, because there's never a hidden agenda with you.

blabbermouth meter 85%

Vault Blabbermouth

♎ Libra

Planet: Venus — Element: Air
🥉
September 23 – October 22
Libra — can't keep a secret

“I don't gossip, I share”

An Air sign, cardinal and ruled by Venus: you're the sign of relationships, and nothing bonds people like a little secret whispered in someone's ear. There isn't a mean bone in your body, but a juicy bit of gossip, well told, is your guilty pleasure.

Your weak spot is wanting to please everyone: if someone pushes with a sweet smile, you cave with “just a tiny hint.” Learn to say “sorry, that's not mine to share” with the same charm. Luckily, your diplomacy keeps your little leaks from turning into drama.

blabbermouth meter 78%

Vault Blabbermouth

♈ Aries

Planet: Mars — Element: Fire
March 21 – April 19
Aries — can't keep a secret

“It came out before I thought about it”

A Fire sign, cardinal and ruled by Mars, the planet of impulse: your mouth takes off before your brain does. You keep a secret perfectly… for the first ten minutes. Then impatience wins, especially when it's good news.

The Christmas present? You hand it over on December 15th because “waiting is way too hard.” It's not nosiness, it's enthusiasm with no brakes. Hide the gift at the neighbor's, and the secret with it. Luckily, you're fiercely loyal: a secret that could hurt someone, you'll guard like a knight.

blabbermouth meter 71%

Vault Blabbermouth

♍ Virgo

Planet: Mercury — Element: Earth
August 23 – September 22
Virgo — can't keep a secret

“I'm not gossiping, I'm correcting”

An Earth sign, reserved by nature, but mutable and ruled by Mercury, the planet of words: you're pretty discreet… until someone tells the story wrong. Then you just can't stop yourself from fixing the details.

That's your trap: you don't spill a secret by chatting, you spill it by being accurate (“No, it wasn't Tuesday, it was Thursday, and she wasn't alone…”). Let one mistake slide, the world won't end. Luckily, about everything else, you're as reliable as a notary.

blabbermouth meter 64%

Vault Blabbermouth

♒ Aquarius

Planet: Uranus — Element: Air
January 20 – February 18
Aquarius — can't keep a secret

“Transparency is my thing”

An Air sign ruled by Uranus, the planet of sudden revelations: to you, secrecy is a slightly weird concept. Why hide what's true? But you're also a fixed sign, and your word matters.

The result: you keep other people's secrets effortlessly… as long as they don't clash with your principles. If you think a truth needs to come out, you drop it without warning, like lightning in a winter sky. Give the person a heads-up before you “set their secret free.” Luckily, you never spread rumors: gossip bores you to tears.

blabbermouth meter 57%

Vault Blabbermouth

♌ Leo

Planet: Sun — Element: Fire
July 23 – August 22
Leo — can't keep a secret

“I'll keep it… but I'll milk the suspense”

A fixed Fire sign ruled by the Sun: you love the spotlight, and a secret is basically a stage waiting for its audience. Your fixed nature makes you loyal: people can count on you not to betray a friend.

Your weakness is the tease: “I know something, but I can't say…” (and everyone begs you all through dessert). Keep the secret without announcing you have one. Luckily, your generosity and sense of honor make you a priceless ally when it really counts.

blabbermouth meter 50%

Vault Blabbermouth

♋ Cancer

Planet: Moon — Element: Water
June 21 – July 22
Cancer — can't keep a secret

“I keep it all… except from family”

Ruled by the Moon, a Water sign and so an introvert by tradition: you're an excellent keeper of secrets, especially matters of the heart. You know what it costs to open up, and you protect the people who trust you.

Your one weak spot is the family circle, where everything comes out over eggnog (“I'm only telling you, so don't tell Mom”). Draw a clear line between what's yours to share and what isn't. Luckily, your loved ones know their feelings are safe with you, like under a warm, cozy blanket.

blabbermouth meter 43%

Vault Blabbermouth

♓ Pisces

Planet: Neptune — Element: Water
February 19 – March 20
Pisces — can't keep a secret

“Your secret sleeps at the bottom of the ocean”

A Water sign ruled by Neptune and linked to the 12th house, the house of hidden things and secrets in traditional astrology: you're a born confidant. People tell you things they've never told anyone, because you listen without judging.

The only risk is your dreamy, mutable nature: on a foggy day, you mix up who told you what, and a secret slips out by accident. Stamp a mental “top secret” label on every secret. Luckily, your empathy makes you the shoulder everyone comes to cry on, and that's a real gift.

blabbermouth meter 36%

Vault Blabbermouth

♉ Taurus

Planet: Venus — Element: Earth
April 20 – May 20
Taurus — can't keep a secret

“What comes in here never goes out”

A fixed Earth sign ruled by Venus: you're as solid as a rock, and just as chatty. To you, a secret is a precious object you put away and never take out again.

It's not even an effort: you simply have no desire to talk about it. You'd rather talk about the Christmas ham. Let your friends know they can confide in you: you're so discreet they forget to ask. Luckily, your calm is reassuring: secrets are as safe with you as in a Swiss bank.

blabbermouth meter 29%

Vault Blabbermouth

♑ Capricorn

Planet: Saturn — Element: Earth
December 22 – January 19
Capricorn — can't keep a secret

“Professional discretion guaranteed”

An Earth sign, cardinal and ruled by Saturn, the planet of restraint and control: discretion is second nature to you, practically a code of conduct. You know information is power, and you don't waste it.

You're the kind of person who hears news at the same time as everyone else, news you've known for six months, and says “Oh, really?” with a perfectly straight face. Still, tell people you trust them, they need to hear it too. Luckily, your reliability earns you everyone's trust.

blabbermouth meter 22%

Vault Blabbermouth

♏ Scorpio

Planet: Pluto — Element: Water
October 23 – November 21
Scorpio — can't keep a secret

“I'm taking this secret to the grave”

A fixed Water sign ruled by Pluto, master of all that's hidden, not to mention the sign's traditional link to the 8th house, the house of mysteries: you're the zodiac's true vault. Whatever people tell you disappears down a bottomless well.

Your little quirk: you keep everyone else's secrets… and collect your own. Nobody really knows what you're thinking, and you like it that way. Share a small secret now and then, trust goes both ways. Luckily, your loyalty is absolute: Archangel Raziel, keeper of secrets, has nothing to teach you.

blabbermouth meter 15%

Vault Blabbermouth

✦

Keeping a Secret: How All 12 Signs Rank 🏅

The longer the bar, the more likely the secret flies out before dessert.

See all 12 signs

✦ ✦

Blabbermouth or Vault, Your Sign Doesn't Decide Everything 🌙

Your Sun sign shows a tendency, not a sentence. Your Moon, your Mercury and your Rising sign add nuance: a Gemini with Scorpio rising can absolutely keep a secret for twenty years (yes, really). And you're always free to choose: keeping a secret is a skill you can learn, just like learning to stay quiet at the right moment… or to speak up when you need to. And for everything your sign keeps to itself without ever admitting it, here's what your zodiac sign secretly thinks. Still hunting for a holiday gift idea? At least avoid the Christmas gift each sign secretly hates.

So, did you recognize yourself? Send this page to the friend who ruined last year's surprise… or to the one who takes all your secrets to the grave. Laughs guaranteed at the holiday party. 😉

✦ ✦

✦ ✦ ✦

3 ways to talk about it

Is a secret weighing on you and you don't know who to tell?

Our psychics are mediators, trained to receive what you're going through and reflect it back in clear language.
Choose the consultation mode that suits your availability... and your courage of the moment.

💌  TO DISCOVER

By email

At your own pace

Describe your sign and your situation. Our psychic will write you a detailed reading within 24 hours. Take your time reading it, rereading it, coming back to it. No pressure.

Deadline48 hours max
FormatDetailed written reading
Write to a psychic
💬  TO EXCHANGE

By chat

Real time without the voice

Chat live with a psychic, without the phone barrier. You read, you write, you formulate. The ideal halfway between written and the intimacy of voice.

DeadlineInstant dialogue
Format15 to 25 minutes
Start a chat
🔥  TO GO DEEPER

By phone

The most complete experience

The voice captures what no text can translate: hesitation, emotion, the energy running through you. For the more adventurous, this is the consultation that takes you furthest.

DeadlineDirect conversation
Format10 to 20 minutes
Call a psychic

All our consultations are offered in partnership with Wengo, the leading platform for psychic and wellbeing services since 2003.

✦250+ psychics certified
✦7/7 · 24/24
✦Secure payment

Find similar articles on this topic :

Susan Taylor

Article presented by
Susan Taylor

"Editor in Chief & Astrologer for MyAstroMag My life's work is decoding the language of the stars to illuminate our human experience. As the Editor in Chief of MyAstroMag, I specialize in the astrology of love and relationships. Through our exclusive horoscopes and forecasts, my mission is to provid..."

Read on

Our latest articles

What color to wear for New Year's Eve to start 2027 right?

Who hasn't experienced that moment of panic in front of their closet, just a few hours before New Year's Eve? Those long minutes spent scrutinizing your clothes wondering "What on earth am I going to wear?" 😅 Don't worry anymore: this year, I'm here to help you choose the perfect outfit that will not only flatter you but also attract all the good energies for 2027!

How to Bring Spirituality Into Your 2027 Resolutions

Lose weight, exercise more, less screen time... and by February, the list is gathering dust in a drawer. What if your resolutions were simply missing roots? Here is the ritual that ties each one to what truly matters to you, then turns it into a small daily gesture, to be done on New Year's Eve or at the first New Moon of 2027.

Yule: How to Celebrate the Magic of the Winter Solstice?

Yule is the festival of the longest night and the return of the light. Inherited from the Germanic peoples and revived by Wicca, it is celebrated at the winter solstice, on December 21 in 2026. Here is what it means, its symbols and a simple ritual you can do at home that evening. 🕯️

2026 Box
Readings
Newsletter
Draws and Games